Top image: San José City Hall, where tenant advocates are taking their campaign for stricter apartment inspections. Photo: HarshLight / CC BY 2.0 via Wikimedia Commons
If you rent an apartment in San José and have reported mold, pests or a leak that never quite got fixed, a new campaign is aimed at you.
Tenants backed by the Law Foundation of Silicon Valley, Latinos United for a New America (LUNA) and the Regional Tenant Organizing Network have launched a “Healthy Homes” campaign asking the City Council for tougher code enforcement in rental housing, San José Spotlight reported this week. The coalition’s headline statistic: of 23,000 code violations filed by residents or documented by inspectors over the past three years, only one case resulted in fines levied by the Appeals Hearing Board, according to the Law Foundation.
The city disputes the framing, if not the number. Marika Krause, spokesperson for the Planning, Building and Code Enforcement Department, told Spotlight that most of those violations were resolved through voluntary compliance without fines.
How inspections work now
San José inspects apartment buildings on a tiered schedule based on each building’s violation history, according to Spotlight. The buildings with the most violations are inspected every three years; others every five or six years. Owners in the lowest tier submit their own annual inspections to the city.
The capacity math is stark. The city has 16 inspectors covering more than 110,000 apartments in roughly 6,750 buildings, according to city data cited by Spotlight. That works out to about 6,900 apartments, or about 420 buildings, per inspector.
Last fiscal year the city issued 32 citations and more than 500 compliance orders, Krause said. Citations, for easily fixed problems like blight or graffiti, carry fines from $25 to $1,000 or more per violation. Compliance orders cover health and safety violations; when owners don’t comply, the appeals board can levy larger fines.
What tenants want
The coalition is asking the council to:
- Replace landlord self-certification with third-party inspections.
- Require building-wide inspections once one apartment has a confirmed violation.
- Register landlords who remain noncompliant.
- Enforce real penalties for violations.
“These issues didn’t start this year,” Cindy Tran, an organizer for the Law Foundation, told Spotlight. “Many of these tenants are long-term renters in San Jose and they feel as though landlords are given chance after chance.”
Tristia Bauman, the Law Foundation’s directing attorney of housing, said voluntary compliance can mean a surface fix, such as scrubbing mold off a wall without repairing the leak behind it. “What we’d like to see are real financial consequences for landlords who are running substandard residential buildings,” she said.
LUNA organizer Gabriel Manrique said the department is understaffed and that tenants often don’t know how to file formal complaints or fear retaliation. The coalition has helped 300 to 400 residents form tenant organizations in South San José, East San José and downtown, Spotlight reported.
What the city says
Krause said the city launched a pilot this spring to impose more severe consequences on landlords who repeatedly leave violations unaddressed. “We are meeting with the coalition and willing to explore how we can align with our work and ultimate goal of improving conditions for tenants,” she said.
Mayor Matt Mahan said he has asked code enforcement managers to meet with the coalition and make sure outstanding cases are fully addressed. “The Law Foundation and our code enforcement department agree that no one should live in unsafe, unsanitary conditions,” he told Spotlight.
What it means for you
If you have a habitability problem now, document it with dated photos and written requests to your landlord, and file a formal complaint with the city’s code enforcement division, which you can reach through San José 311. Tenants who fear retaliation can contact the Law Foundation of Silicon Valley, which provides free legal help to eligible renters. Because inspection tiers are set by each building’s violation history, a documented record is what the system is built to respond to.
The long view
Most of San José’s housing debate has centered on building more. Keeping the existing stock livable is the less glamorous half of the same problem, and the cheapest affordable apartment is the one that does not fall into disrepair. With 16 inspectors for more than 110,000 units, any serious overhaul will come down to a budget decision. Watch whether the coalition’s proposals reach a council committee, and what the city’s repeat-offender pilot shows when its results are reported.
Leave a Reply